| 1991 Fossil Schedule | |||||||
| Date | Field | Opponent | H/V | Result | |||
| 5/13 | Olivet #2 | Redeemer Lutheran | H | L 17-1 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 5/20 | Olivet #1 | Olivet Baptist Red | H | L 19-7 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 6/3 | Olivet #1 | Valley Community Pres. | H | L 21-17 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 6/10 | Valley Place #2 | Elim Baptist #1 | V | L 15-1 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 6/17 | Olivet #2 | Crystal Free | V | L 21-18 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 6/24 | Valley Place #2 | Plymouth Bible | V | L 15-13 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 7/1 | Olivet #2 | Maple Grove Free | H | L 23-12 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 7/8 | Olivet #1 | Valley Baptist | V | W 14-5 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 7/15 | Valley Place #2 | Solid Rock | V | W 8-5 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |
| 7/22 | Olivet #2 | Elim Lutheran Gold | V | W 23-7 | Recap | Box Score | Matchup History |